Committee's support for Vale planning concerns 'is too little, too late'

Thu 19 Nov 2026

A States committee's support for Vale Douzaine concerns over the impact of building 1,000 new homes in the north of the island is welcome – but actually too little, too late.

Screenshot 2026 11 18 At 10.35.52
1. Parc Le Lacheur, 2.Saltpans/Datapark, 3. Franc Fief, 4. Pointues Rocques, 5.Fontaine Vinery, (formerly Belgrave Vinery).

Constable Richard Leale said it was helpful that Environment & Infrastructure's president, Deputy Adrian Gabriel, had reached the same conclusion as the Vale Douzaine and colleagues in St Sampson's over the scale of proposed development in the north.

"However, my initial response is that this is too little, too late," said Mr Leale. "All the infrastructure issues should have been properly addressed before these large development areas were identified."

Under something called a Strategic Delivery Framework, the States has identified the five areas pictured above, which have the potential to accommodate 1,000 new homes, and has asked consultants Ridge and Partners to bring together all the relevant elements of the development and its wider impacts at this late stage.

"What this really means is that the latest consultants have been tasked with fitting a quart into a pint pot," said Mr Leale. "How many more reports will be produced in an attempt to justify fitting so many houses into a finite space?" he asked.

Kicked around

He said that Environment & Infrastructure had kicked this issue around for years, under different presidents and with different "solutions", such as active travel, aimed at persuading people out of their cars. However, the biggest fly in the ointment was the attempt to cram too much into a small space, creating the problems in the first place.

Mr Leale said the other aspect being overlooked was that these mega-schemes were not a quick fix for the island's housing crisis, but were planned over a timescale of up to 20 years, partly to help protect existing market prices and property owners.

"The Vale Douzaine has repeatedly said that there is an urgent need to create new homes for islanders, and that smaller schemes spread around the island, rather than concentrated in the north, would produce far quicker results at a more affordable price," he said.

Mr Leale set out the Douzaine's position in detail in this article, and the Guernsey Press asked Environment & Infrastructure for its comments on the concerns raised.

Planning matters

Environment & Infrastructure president Adrian Gabriel and vice-president Sally Rochester agree that land-use and transport planning are closely linked, and that decisions on housing, employment and retail development can significantly affect traffic, road capacity, parking demand, public transport and active travel.

While the planning review would determine whether changes to planning policy were appropriate, they said it was "equally important to understand whether the island's transport network can accommodate those changes and, if not, what interventions may be required".

"Planning decisions are most effective when supported by appropriate infrastructure," they said.

  • An amendment to the States' review of the Island Development Plan would direct E&I to identify the transport implications of any decisions arising from the review, and the resources needed to deliver a "whole-island transport response", with any funding requests going first to the Policy and Resources Committee.

Have something to contribute? Send us a message
Share This Page

website by Submarine